Guides / Texas take-backs
Guide · 6 minute read · Last checked Nov 2026Texas rules when a dental insurer takes back a payment
In Texas, a dental plan may not recover an overpayment from a dentist unless it sends written notice, with the basis and specific reasons, no later than the 180th day after the dentist received the payment (Tex. Ins. Code §1451.206(d)). The dentist then has until the 45th day after receiving that notice to object in writing; if the dentist objects, the plan can recover only after the dentist exhausts all rights of appeal.
The same chapter bars a plan from deducting an overpayment from a payment for a service by a dentist who did not receive the overpayment (§1451.207(a)(5)).
Which plans it covers
- Covered: a health insurance policy delivered, issued for delivery or renewed on or after Jan 1, 2024, and an employee benefit plan for a plan year starting on or after Jan 1, 2024 (H.B. 1527, section 4), under Chapter 1451, Subchapter E.
- Not covered: an HMO governed by Chapter 843, so dental HMO plans (§1451.202(b)).
- Regulated elsewhere: TDI says it doesn't regulate self-funded plans, Medicaid, CHIP plans that aren't HMOs, Medicare, military plans, or city, county, state and federal employee plans. Federal law (ERISA, 29 U.S.C. §1144) supersedes state laws that relate to employee benefit plans. See which plans Texas law covers.
Step by step
- Find the take-back. On an 835 it is often a provider-level adjustment (PLB) whose reference points to the earlier claim; on a paper EOB, a negative line or a “recovery” note. See how to read an EOB and 835.
- Find the original payment: the date your office received it. The 180 days count from that day.
- Find the written notice. Did one come before the money was taken? Write down the day you received it and whether it gives the basis and specific reasons.
- Count: 180 days from the payment to the notice; 45 days from the day you got the notice.
- If you disagree, object in writing before the 45th day, following the plan's written procedure: §1451.206(e) requires plans to have written policies and procedures that let you challenge the request and access the claims information in dispute. Ask for that information.
- Keep copies of the notice, your objection and proof of when it went out.
Example (made up)
Your office received a $412 payment on March 3, 2026. The 180th day after it is August 30, 2026. A recovery notice dated September 25 arrives on October 1, 2026: later than the 180th day. Under §1451.206(d) (if the plan is covered), the plan may not recover the overpayment. Had the notice arrived on June 1, 2026, the 45th day after it would be July 16, 2026: your written objection would be due on or before that day.
The statute counts from the day the dentist receives the payment or the notice. A payment file shows the insurer's payment date, which can be a few days earlier, so treat dates worked out from it as approximate.
Questions
How long does a dental insurer have to take back an overpayment in Texas?
Under Tex. Ins. Code §1451.206(d), it may not recover the overpayment unless it sends written notice, with the basis and specific reasons, not later than the 180th day after the dentist receives the payment. It applies to policies delivered, issued or renewed on or after Jan 1, 2024 (for an employer's benefit plan, plan years starting on or after that date), and not to dental HMOs (§1451.202(b)).
How long do I have to object to a dental recoupment in Texas?
The plan may recover the money if the dentist doesn't object in writing or arrange repayment on or before the 45th day after receiving the notice, or if the dentist objects and exhausts all rights of appeal (§1451.206(d)(2)). Object in writing before that 45th day.
Can a Texas dental insurer take money from one dentist's claims for another dentist's overpayment?
No: §1451.207(a)(5) bars deducting an overpayment from a payment for a dental service provided by a dentist who did not receive the overpayment.
Find the money insurers took back. Create a free account, run the free check, and open the demo to see take-backs traced to the claim they came from when the payment file names it.
Owedex accounts open to everyone at app.owedex.com once our email service is approved; until then, email demo@owedex.com for a demo.
Sources
- Texas Insurance Code Chapter 1451, Subchapter E (§§1451.201–1451.209), Texas Legislature
- H.B. 1527 (88th Legislature, 2023), enrolled text: §1451.206(d)–(e) and which plans it applies to
- Texas Department of Insurance: Getting help with a health plan that TDI doesn't regulate
- 29 U.S.C. §1144 (ERISA §514), other laws: preemption and the "deemer" clause (Cornell LII)
Last checked Nov 2026. Laws and insurer pages change: open the source before you rely on it.
General information for dental billing staff, not legal advice. Plan terms, contracts and insurer rules vary: check the patient's plan, your contract and the insurer's provider manual.